Japan, known for its workaholic culture made headlines when its government was reported to be considering passing a law which force its workers to take leave. There are many reasons that contribute to such a drastic decision including the thought that this move could help to revive Japan’s economic growth after years of stagnation.
But is it really that simple? Do more leave days equate to increased productivity?
While there are many articles written on the Internet (including one of our very own) that say YES, fewer work days lead to higher productivity, the data is incomplete or usually uses only one country as a focal point. We thought we’d give the data a second look, and going much bigger with this.
So here’s what We Did
You may have come across reports that mention Switzerland as the most productive country, based on a Global Competitiveness Report. We’ve looked into the methodology and found that they fall back on the Global Competitiveness Index (GCI) as "an appropriate estimate of the level of productivity and competitiveness of an economy."
Technically, the higher up a country is ranked on this report, the higher the productivity of the country.
So we pulled the top 30 most competitive countries as ranked by the Global Competitiveness Report 2014/2015 and found the four following sets of data for comparison:
- average working hours per week
- minimum annual leave mandated by law
- days of parental leave allocated for each country
- parental leave mandated by law
Note: The data here is correct as pulled from their sources on Feb, 2015. Our sources are available at the bottom of the table.
Working Hours And Leave By Countries
Country | Working hrs per Week | Minimum Mandated Annual Leave (days) | Paid Public Holidays | Paid Vacation Days | Parental leave |
(1) Switzerland | 30 hrs* | 20 days | N/A | 20 days | 14 weeks |
(2) Singapore | 40 hrs | 8-14 days | 11 days | 7 days | 16 weeks |
(3) United States | 34 hrs* | 0 days; 6-20 days (doe) | 0 days | 0 days | 0 days |
(4) Finland | 32 hrs* | 30 days | 9 days | 25 days | 15 weeks |
(5) Germany | 27 hrs* | 24 days | 10-14 days (depending on state) | 20 days | 14 weeks |
(6) Japan | 33 hrs* | 10 days; +1 day off for each yos (max: 20 days) | N/A | 10 days | 14 weeks |
(7) Hong Kong | 40 hrs | 7-14 days (depending yos) | N/A | 7 days | 10 weeks |
(8) Netherlands | 27 hrs* | 20 days | 10 days | 20 days | 16 weeks |
(9) United Kingdom | 32 hrs* | 28 days | 8 days (9 for Scotland) | 28 days | 39 weeks |
(10) Sweden | 31 hrs* | 25 days | N/A | 25 days | 480 days |
(11) Norway | 27 hrs* | 25 days | 2 days | 21 days | 56 or 46 weeks |
(12) United Arab Emirates | 40 hrs | 2 days/month for 1st year; 30 days for > 1 yos | 10 days | 25 days | 45 days |
(13) Denmark | 27 hrs* | 30 days | 9 days | 25 days | 52 weeks |
(14) Taiwan | 40 hrs | 7-30 days (dependent on yos) | 25 days | 7 days | 8 weeks |
(15) Canada | 33 hrs* | 10 days | 5-10 days (depending on province) | 10 days | 50 weeks |
(16) Qatar | 40 hrs | 15-20 days | 10 days | 15 days | 50 days |
(17) New Zealand | 34 hrs* | 20 days | 11 days | 20 days | 14 weeks |
(18) Belgium | 30 hrs* | 20-24 days (dependent on working days a week) | 10 days | 20 days | 15 weeks |
(19) Luxembourg | 32 hrs* | 25 days (extra 6 days of for workers with disabilities) | 10 days | 25 days | 16 weeks |
(20) Malaysia | 40 hrs | 8-16 days (depending on yos) | 19 days | 7 days | 60 days |
(21) Austria | 31 hrs* | 30-36 days (dependent on yos) | 13 days | 30/35 days | 16 weeks |
(22) Australia | 32 hrs* | 20 days (25 days for shiftworkers) | 9-11 days | 20 days | 18 weeks |
(23) France | 29 hrs* | 30 days (extra 22 days for > 35 working hrs/week) | 1 day | 25 days | 16 weeks; 26 weeks for third child. |
(24) Saudi Arabia | 48 hrs | 21-30 days (dependent on yos) | 10 days | 15 days | 10 weeks |
(25) Ireland | 35 hrs* | 20 days | 9 days | 20 days | 26 weeks |
(26) South Korea | 42 hrs* | 15-25 days (dependent on yos) | N/A | 15 days | 90 days |
(27) Israel | 36 hrs* | 10-28 days (dependent on yos) | N/A | 10 days | 14 weeks |
(28) China | 44 hrs | 5-15 days (dependent on yos) | 11 days | 5 days | 98 days |
(29) Estonia | 36 hrs* | 28 days (dependent on contract) | N/A | 20 days | 140 days (extra 2 wks for medical complications) |
(30) Iceland | 33 hrs* | 24 days | 12 days | 24 days | 90 days |
*doe – depending on employer;
*yos – year of service
Sources:
- Top 30 Most Competitive Countries, Global Competitive Report
- List of statutory minimum employment leave by country, Wikipedia
- *Average annual hrs actually worked per worker, OECD
- Workweek and weekend, Wikipedia
- Parental leave, Wikipedia
Leaderboard
Now, we understand that the table above is contains a truckload of data and who has the vacation time to go through the data cell by cell, right? In this section we will just give you the summary for each category, in what we will call the leaderboards.
Let’s start with the working hours in a week.
Countries with the most working hours:
- 48 hrs – Saudi Arabia
- 44 hrs – China
- 42 hrs – South Korea
- 40 hrs – Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia, Qatar, United Arab Emirates,
- 36 hrs – Israel, Estonia
Countries with the Least working hours:
- 27 hrs – Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Denmark
- 29 hrs – France
- 30 hrs – Switzerland, Belgium
- 31 hrs – Sweden, Austria
- 32 hrs – Luxembourg, Australia
If you are looking for the country that tops the chart in highest number of mandated annual leave, check this out:
Countries With Most Annual Leave (days):
- 30 days – Finland, France, Denmark, Austria
- 28 days – United Kingdom, Estonia
- 24 days – Germany, Iceland
- 25 days – Sweden, Norway, Luxembourg
- 21 days – Saudi Arabia
Countries With Least Annual Leave (days):
- 0 days – United States
- 5 days – China
- 7 days – Taiwan, Hong Kong
- 8 days – Singapore, Malaysia
- 10 days – Israel, Canada, Japan
If you wonder if vacation days actually have the influence on productivity in the workplace, then these are the leaderboards you want to see.
Countries With The Most Paid Vacation Days:
- 30 days – Austria
- 28 days – United Kingdom
- 25 days – Finland, Sweden, United Arab Emirates, Denmark, Luxembourg, France
- 24 days – Iceland
- 21 days – Norway
Countries With The Least Paid Vacation Days:
- 0 days – United States
- 5 days – China
- 7 days – Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan, Malaysia
- 10 days – Japan, Canada, Israel
- 15 days – Qatar, Saudi Arabia, South Korea
Parental leave, a controversial topic for many countries including the United States. Here are the countries that give parents a whole lot of time off, and those that didn’t.
Countries With The Longest Parental Leave:
- 480 days – Sweden
- 56 weeks – Norway
- 52 weeks – Denmark
- 50 weeks – Canada
- 26 weeks – Ireland
Countries With The Shortest Parental Leave:
- 45 days – United Arab Emirates
- 50 days – Qatar
- 8 weeks – Taiwan
- 60 days – Malaysia
- 10 weeks – Hong Kong, Saudi Arabia
Lastly, here are the leaderboards on paid public holidays, also known as holidays that you get to take a break while still on a payroll.
Countries With The Most Paid Public Holidays:
- 25 days – Taiwan
- 19 days – Malaysia
- 13 days – Austria
- 12 days – Iceland
- 11 days – Singapore
Countries With The Least Paid Public Holidays:
- 0 days – United States
- 1 day – France
- 2 days – Norway
- 5 days – Canada
- 8 days – United Kingdom
Visual Aid
To our readers who adopt the tl;dr approach, here’s an infographic that can help you better visualize the amount of data featured here, designed by our friends in Piktochart.
Editor’s note: This infographic is available at Piktochart and is free to use.
Conclusion
While our methods are far from scientific, we’re not seeing a pattern where more vacation days is contributing to higher productivity or competitiveness of a particular country. Then again, the data is all here and up for your scrutiny and interpretation.
Let us know what you think.
Could More Vacation Time Improve Your Productivity? [30 Countries Compared]
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.